Division of Endocrinology, Department of Systems Medicine, University of Rome Tor Vergata, Rome, Italy.
Copyright © 2019 Korean Diabetes Association
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
CONFLICTS OF INTEREST: Vincenza Spallone has received research grants from Biocure srl Italy and Boehringer Ingelheim Italy. She has received remunerations for lectures or consultations for AWP srl Italy, Boehringer Ingelheim Italy, Daiichi Sankyo Europe, Ely-Lilly Italy, IRIS Servier France, Laborest Italy, Pfizer Italy, Sanofi Aventis Italy, Schwarz Pharma Europe, Wörwag Pharma Germany. She has served on advisory boards for Angelini S.p.A Italy, TRIGOcare International Germany, and Wörwag Pharma GmbH & Co Germany.
Study | Study design and setting | No. and category | CAN measures | CAN prevalence | Differences vs. NGT | CAN correlatesa |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Annuzzi et al. (1983) [4] | Hospital diabetes clinic; Italy | 124 NGT, 62 IGT | DB | Not provided | No differences | Age, BMI |
Fujimoto et al. (1987) [5] | Community-based study; USA (Japanese-American men) | 79 NGT, 72 IGT | DB | Not provided | No differences | Fasting glucose |
Gerritsen et al. (2000) [6] | Hoorn study; the Netherlands | 288 NGT, 169 IGT | Short-term HRV, BRS, DB, LS, OH | Not provided | ↓SDNN | Age, antihypertensive drugsa |
Singh et al. (2000) [7] | Framingham Heart Study; USA | 1,779 NFG, 56 IFG | Short-term HRV | Not provided | ↓SDNN, HF and LF. Differences no more present after adjusting for covariates | Fasting glucose |
Schroeder et al. (2005) [8] | ARIC study; USA | 5,410 NFG, 3,561 IFG | Short-term HRV | Not provided | ↓RR interval and rMSSD at baseline. No differences in the rate of change in HRV | Fasting glucose (weak association at baseline) |
Perciaccante et al. (2006) [9] | Hospital diabetes clinic; Italy | 20 control, 20 IFG, 20 IGT | 24 hr HRV | Not provided | ↓SDNN, low TP, and ↑LFnu in IFG and IGT | HOMA-I |
Stein et al. (2007) [10] | Cardiovascular Health Study; USA | 536 NFG, 545 IFG | 24 hr HRV | Not provided | ↓RR interval, SDNN and TP in IFG subgroup 2 (fasting glucose 6.1–6.9 mmol/L) | Fasting glucose, metabolic syndrome componentsa |
Wu et al. (2007) [11] | Population-based study; Taiwan | 983 NGT, 163 IFG, 188 IGT | Short-term HRV, DB, LS | Not provided | ↓SDNN and DB in IFG and IGT; ↓LS and HF in IGT; only IGT associated with LS, HF power and LF:HF after adjustment | Not provided |
Isak et al. (2008) [12] | University clinic; Turkey | 25 NGT, 25 IGT | DB, LS, VM, OH, Handgrip, Sudomotor function | Not provided | No differences apart from in sympathetic skin response | Not provided |
Laitinen et al. (2011) [13] | Finnish Diabetes Prevention Study; Finland | 268 IGT | DB, OH | 25% Abnormal DB, 6% abnormal OH | Not provided (no control group) | Age, BMI, waist, triglycerides (in men) |
Putz et al. (2013) [14] | Hospital diabetes clinic; Hungary | 40 NGT, 75 IGT | DB, LS, VM, OH Handgrip test, Triangle index | IGT: 57.5% one abnormal test | ↓DB, Valsalva ratio, OH, handgrip test, and triangle index | Not provided |
Ziegler et al. (2015) [15] | KORA S4 Study; Germany (55–74 yr) | 565 NGT, 336 IFG, 72 IGT, 151 IFG-IGT | 4 Out of 120 short-term HRV indices | NGT: 4.5% | 4 and 6 HRV measures more frequently abnormal in IFG and IFG-IGT, respectively | HR, BMI, hypertension, smoking, creatinine, drugs suppressing HRV as predictors of diminished HRVa |
IFG: 8.1% | ||||||
IGT: 5.9% | ||||||
IFG-IGT: 11.4% | ||||||
Tiftikcioglu et al. (2016) [16] | Hospital neurology clinic; Turkey | 30 NGT, 25 IGT | Short-term HRV, Sudomotor function | Not provided | ↓SDNN, CV, TP, LF, LF:HF in IGT | Not provided |
Dimova et al. (2017) [17] | Hospital diabetes clinic; Bulgaria | 1,130 NGT, 25 IFG, 102 IGT | 8 Short-term HRV indices | NGT: 12.3% | ↓Sympathetic and parasympathetic spectral indices in IFG and IGT | Age, QTc-i, waist for sympathetic and parasympathetic indices;a DBP, 2 hr BG for sympathetic indicesa |
IFG: 13.2% | ||||||
IGT: 20.6% |
CAN, cardiovascular autonomic neuropathy; NGT, normal glucose tolerance; IGT, impaired glucose tolerance; DB, deep breathing; BMI, body mass index; HRV, heart rate variability; BRS, baroreflex sensitivity; LS, lying to standing; OH, orthostatic hypotension; SDNN, standard deviation of NN intervals; IFG, impaired fasting glucose; HF, high-frequency spectral component of heart rate variability; LF, low-frequency spectral component of heart rate variability; RR, coefficient of variation; rMSSD, root means successive square difference; TP, total power of heart rate variability; nu, normalized units; HOMA-I, homeostatic model assessment index; VM, Valsalva manoeuvre; QTc-i, corrected QT interval; DBP, diastolic blood pressure; BG, blood glucose.
aVariables found to be related to CAN in multivariate analysis.
Study | No. and type | CAN testing | Follow-up, yr | Kidney function outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|
Sundkvist et al. (1993) [59] | 35 T1DM | DB, Tilt test | 10 | CAN predictor of D GFR and associated with ↓GFR |
Weinrauch et al. (1998) [60] | 26 T1DM with proteinuria | DB, LS, VM | 1 | VM predictor of D creatinine and renal failure |
Burger et al. (2002) [61] | 23 T1DM with macroalbuminuria | DB, LS, VM, HRV indices | 1 | HRV indexes associated with D GFR ≥8 mL/min |
Forsen et al. (2004) [62] | 58 T1DM | DB, Tilt test, OH | 7–14 | DB associated with 14 years UAE OH predictor of 7 years D GFR |
Astrup et al. (2006) [63] | 388 T1DM with micro-macroalbuminuria | DB | 10 | DB not predictor of D GFR |
Maguire et al. (2007) [64] | 137 T1DM with normoalbuminuria | Pupillary light test | 12 | Small pupil size predictor of micro |
Kim et al. (2009) [65] | 156 T2DM with normoalbuminuria | DB, LS, VM, OH | 9 | DB predictor of D eGFR |
Brotman et al. (2010) [66] ARIC Study | 13,241 (1,523 with diabetes) | Heart rate, HRV indices | 16 | Heart rate and HRV predictors of ESRD |
Tahrani et al. (2014) [67] | 204 T2DM without ESDR | DB, LS, VM, OH | 2.5 | CAN predictor of eGFR decline |
Orlov et al. (2015) [68] 1st Joslin Kidney Study |
204 T1DM with normoalbuminuria 166 T1DM with microalbuminuria |
MCR during DB | 14 | MCR <20 predictor of eGFR loss (odds ratio, 4.09) and of CKD stage ≥3 |
Yun et al. (2015) [69] | 755 T2DM without CKD | DB, LS, VM, OH | 9.6 | Confirmed CAN predictor of CKD (hazard ratio, 2.62) |
CAN, cardiovascular autonomic neuropathy; T1DM, type 1 diabetes mellitus; DB, deep breathing; GFR, glomerular filtration rate; LS, lying to standing; VM, Valsalva manoeuvre; HRV, heart rate variability; OH, orthostatic hypotension; UAE, urinary albumin excretion; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus; eGFR, estimated glomerular filtration rate; ESRD, end-stage renal disease; MCR, mean circular resultant; CKD, chronic kidney disease.
Toronto Consensus (2011) [12] | Position Statement ADA (2017) [83] | Position Statement AACE/ACE (2018) [95] | SID/AMD Standards (2018) [96] | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Symptoms | Screening | Screening | Screening | Screening |
Signs | Screening | Screening | Screening | Screening |
CARTs | Gold standard for diagnosis | Possible utility in asymptomatic patients | Screening | Diagnosis |
HRV (time- and frequency-domain indices) | Prognostic information | Research | Clinical use in addition to CARTs | Research |
Candidates | Universal screening of symptoms and signs | Those with microvascular complications and/or hypoglycaemia unawareness | Those with T2DM from diagnosis, or T1DM after 5 years | In particular in those with high CV risk and complications |
CAN, cardiovascular autonomic neuropathy; ADA, American Diabetes Association; AACE, American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists; ACE, American College of Endocrinology; SID, Italian Society of Diabetology; AMD, Italian Association of Clinical Diabetologists; CART, cardiovascular autonomic reflex test; HRV, heart rate variability; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus; T1DM, type 1 diabetes mellitus; CV, cardiovascular.
Study | Design | Population | Methodology | Results | Comments | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BP | Cardiovascular outcomes | |||||
Tofe Povedano et al. (2009) [167] | Open-label crossover study | 40 T2DM, hypertensive subjects | Olmesartan 40 mg in the morning or at bedtime | ↓Nighttime =24 hr | Not evaluated | |
16 wk | ||||||
Hermida et al. (2011) [168] | Randomized, open-label, blinded end-point study | 448 T2DM, hypertensive subjects | All hypertension medications upon waking or ≥1 at bedtime | ↓Nighttime =24 hr | ↓Mortality and events | 12% risk reduction per each 5 mm Hg decrease in nighttime systolic BP during follow-up |
5.6 yr (MAPEC study) | ||||||
Rossen et al. (2014) [169] | Open-label crossover study | 41 T2DM subjects with nocturnal hypertension | Morning or bedtime administration of all antihypertensive drugs | ↓Nighttime ↓24 hr =Daytime | Not evaluated | ↑Morning urinary sodium/creatinine. |
16 wk | ||||||
Hjortkjaer et al. (2016) [170] | Randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind crossover study | 24 T1DM subjects with CAN and nondipping | Bedtime versus morning dosing of enalapril 20 mg (plus other medications) | ↑Dipping =BP | Not evaluated | No effects on left ventricular hypertrophy |
24 wk |
Study | Study design and setting | No. and category | CAN measures | CAN prevalence | Differences vs. NGT | CAN correlatesa |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Annuzzi et al. (1983) [ | Hospital diabetes clinic; Italy | 124 NGT, 62 IGT | DB | Not provided | No differences | Age, BMI |
Fujimoto et al. (1987) [ | Community-based study; USA (Japanese-American men) | 79 NGT, 72 IGT | DB | Not provided | No differences | Fasting glucose |
Gerritsen et al. (2000) [ | Hoorn study; the Netherlands | 288 NGT, 169 IGT | Short-term HRV, BRS, DB, LS, OH | Not provided | ↓SDNN | Age, antihypertensive drugsa |
Singh et al. (2000) [ | Framingham Heart Study; USA | 1,779 NFG, 56 IFG | Short-term HRV | Not provided | ↓SDNN, HF and LF. Differences no more present after adjusting for covariates | Fasting glucose |
Schroeder et al. (2005) [ | ARIC study; USA | 5,410 NFG, 3,561 IFG | Short-term HRV | Not provided | ↓RR interval and rMSSD at baseline. No differences in the rate of change in HRV | Fasting glucose (weak association at baseline) |
Perciaccante et al. (2006) [ | Hospital diabetes clinic; Italy | 20 control, 20 IFG, 20 IGT | 24 hr HRV | Not provided | ↓SDNN, low TP, and ↑LFnu in IFG and IGT | HOMA-I |
Stein et al. (2007) [ | Cardiovascular Health Study; USA | 536 NFG, 545 IFG | 24 hr HRV | Not provided | ↓RR interval, SDNN and TP in IFG subgroup 2 (fasting glucose 6.1–6.9 mmol/L) | Fasting glucose, metabolic syndrome componentsa |
Wu et al. (2007) [ | Population-based study; Taiwan | 983 NGT, 163 IFG, 188 IGT | Short-term HRV, DB, LS | Not provided | ↓SDNN and DB in IFG and IGT; ↓LS and HF in IGT; only IGT associated with LS, HF power and LF:HF after adjustment | Not provided |
Isak et al. (2008) [ | University clinic; Turkey | 25 NGT, 25 IGT | DB, LS, VM, OH, Handgrip, Sudomotor function | Not provided | No differences apart from in sympathetic skin response | Not provided |
Laitinen et al. (2011) [ | Finnish Diabetes Prevention Study; Finland | 268 IGT | DB, OH | 25% Abnormal DB, 6% abnormal OH | Not provided (no control group) | Age, BMI, waist, triglycerides (in men) |
Putz et al. (2013) [ | Hospital diabetes clinic; Hungary | 40 NGT, 75 IGT | DB, LS, VM, OH Handgrip test, Triangle index | IGT: 57.5% one abnormal test | ↓DB, Valsalva ratio, OH, handgrip test, and triangle index | Not provided |
Ziegler et al. (2015) [ | KORA S4 Study; Germany (55–74 yr) | 565 NGT, 336 IFG, 72 IGT, 151 IFG-IGT | 4 Out of 120 short-term HRV indices | NGT: 4.5% | 4 and 6 HRV measures more frequently abnormal in IFG and IFG-IGT, respectively | HR, BMI, hypertension, smoking, creatinine, drugs suppressing HRV as predictors of diminished HRVa |
IFG: 8.1% | ||||||
IGT: 5.9% | ||||||
IFG-IGT: 11.4% | ||||||
Tiftikcioglu et al. (2016) [ | Hospital neurology clinic; Turkey | 30 NGT, 25 IGT | Short-term HRV, Sudomotor function | Not provided | ↓SDNN, CV, TP, LF, LF:HF in IGT | Not provided |
Dimova et al. (2017) [ | Hospital diabetes clinic; Bulgaria | 1,130 NGT, 25 IFG, 102 IGT | 8 Short-term HRV indices | NGT: 12.3% | ↓Sympathetic and parasympathetic spectral indices in IFG and IGT | Age, QTc-i, waist for sympathetic and parasympathetic indices;a DBP, 2 hr BG for sympathetic indicesa |
IFG: 13.2% | ||||||
IGT: 20.6% |
Study | No. and type | CAN testing | Follow-up, yr | Kidney function outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|
Sundkvist et al. (1993) [ | 35 T1DM | DB, Tilt test | 10 | CAN predictor of D GFR and associated with ↓GFR |
Weinrauch et al. (1998) [ | 26 T1DM with proteinuria | DB, LS, VM | 1 | VM predictor of D creatinine and renal failure |
Burger et al. (2002) [ | 23 T1DM with macroalbuminuria | DB, LS, VM, HRV indices | 1 | HRV indexes associated with D GFR ≥8 mL/min |
Forsen et al. (2004) [ | 58 T1DM | DB, Tilt test, OH | 7–14 | DB associated with 14 years UAE OH predictor of 7 years D GFR |
Astrup et al. (2006) [ | 388 T1DM with micro-macroalbuminuria | DB | 10 | DB not predictor of D GFR |
Maguire et al. (2007) [ | 137 T1DM with normoalbuminuria | Pupillary light test | 12 | Small pupil size predictor of micro |
Kim et al. (2009) [ | 156 T2DM with normoalbuminuria | DB, LS, VM, OH | 9 | DB predictor of D eGFR |
Brotman et al. (2010) [ | 13,241 (1,523 with diabetes) | Heart rate, HRV indices | 16 | Heart rate and HRV predictors of ESRD |
Tahrani et al. (2014) [ | 204 T2DM without ESDR | DB, LS, VM, OH | 2.5 | CAN predictor of eGFR decline |
Orlov et al. (2015) [ | 204 T1DM with normoalbuminuria 166 T1DM with microalbuminuria | MCR during DB | 14 | MCR <20 predictor of eGFR loss (odds ratio, 4.09) and of CKD stage ≥3 |
Yun et al. (2015) [ | 755 T2DM without CKD | DB, LS, VM, OH | 9.6 | Confirmed CAN predictor of CKD (hazard ratio, 2.62) |
Toronto Consensus (2011) [ | Position Statement ADA (2017) [ | Position Statement AACE/ACE (2018) [ | SID/AMD Standards (2018) [ | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Symptoms | Screening | Screening | Screening | Screening |
Signs | Screening | Screening | Screening | Screening |
CARTs | Gold standard for diagnosis | Possible utility in asymptomatic patients | Screening | Diagnosis |
HRV (time- and frequency-domain indices) | Prognostic information | Research | Clinical use in addition to CARTs | Research |
Candidates | Universal screening of symptoms and signs | Those with microvascular complications and/or hypoglycaemia unawareness | Those with T2DM from diagnosis, or T1DM after 5 years | In particular in those with high CV risk and complications |
Study | Design | Population | Methodology | Results | Comments | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
BP | Cardiovascular outcomes | |||||
Tofe Povedano et al. (2009) [ | Open-label crossover study | 40 T2DM, hypertensive subjects | Olmesartan 40 mg in the morning or at bedtime | ↓Nighttime =24 hr | Not evaluated | |
16 wk | ||||||
Hermida et al. (2011) [ | Randomized, open-label, blinded end-point study | 448 T2DM, hypertensive subjects | All hypertension medications upon waking or ≥1 at bedtime | ↓Nighttime =24 hr | ↓Mortality and events | 12% risk reduction per each 5 mm Hg decrease in nighttime systolic BP during follow-up |
5.6 yr (MAPEC study) | ||||||
Rossen et al. (2014) [ | Open-label crossover study | 41 T2DM subjects with nocturnal hypertension | Morning or bedtime administration of all antihypertensive drugs | ↓Nighttime ↓24 hr =Daytime | Not evaluated | ↑Morning urinary sodium/creatinine. |
16 wk | ||||||
Hjortkjaer et al. (2016) [ | Randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind crossover study | 24 T1DM subjects with CAN and nondipping | Bedtime versus morning dosing of enalapril 20 mg (plus other medications) | ↑Dipping =BP | Not evaluated | No effects on left ventricular hypertrophy |
24 wk |
CAN, cardiovascular autonomic neuropathy; NGT, normal glucose tolerance; IGT, impaired glucose tolerance; DB, deep breathing; BMI, body mass index; HRV, heart rate variability; BRS, baroreflex sensitivity; LS, lying to standing; OH, orthostatic hypotension; SDNN, standard deviation of NN intervals; IFG, impaired fasting glucose; HF, high-frequency spectral component of heart rate variability; LF, low-frequency spectral component of heart rate variability; RR, coefficient of variation; rMSSD, root means successive square difference; TP, total power of heart rate variability; nu, normalized units; HOMA-I, homeostatic model assessment index; VM, Valsalva manoeuvre; QTc-i, corrected QT interval; DBP, diastolic blood pressure; BG, blood glucose. aVariables found to be related to CAN in multivariate analysis.
CAN, cardiovascular autonomic neuropathy; T1DM, type 1 diabetes mellitus; DB, deep breathing; GFR, glomerular filtration rate; LS, lying to standing; VM, Valsalva manoeuvre; HRV, heart rate variability; OH, orthostatic hypotension; UAE, urinary albumin excretion; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus; eGFR, estimated glomerular filtration rate; ESRD, end-stage renal disease; MCR, mean circular resultant; CKD, chronic kidney disease.
CAN, cardiovascular autonomic neuropathy; ADA, American Diabetes Association; AACE, American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists; ACE, American College of Endocrinology; SID, Italian Society of Diabetology; AMD, Italian Association of Clinical Diabetologists; CART, cardiovascular autonomic reflex test; HRV, heart rate variability; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus; T1DM, type 1 diabetes mellitus; CV, cardiovascular.
BP, blood pressure; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus; MAPEC, Monitorización Ambulatoria para Predicción de Eventos Cardiovasculares; T1DM, type 1 diabetes mellitus; CAN, cardiovascular autonomic neuropathy.